"Touching Spirit Bear" Group Discussion #2

On February 26th, my group and I held our second group discussion of "Touching Spirit Bear", focusing on Chapters 10-19.  In this discussion we focused on critical thinking and characterization.  These chapters highlighted Cole's development and changes in attitude.  He went from not caring if he died to having a strong will to live.  We came up with a list of discussion questions that would get students to focus on Cole's character and changing attitudes as the story progressed.  For example:

*What was the significance of the mouse?
(This was a disturbing visual image of this young boy eating a mouse.  As disgusting as it was, it was crucial because it showed that Cole did not want to die anymore, and that he would do anything necessary in order to survive.)

We also came up with questions that would spark students' critical thinking skills within the context of this story.

*What do you think encouraged Cole's shift in attitude from his indifference about death to his will to live?
*Do you think the father's absence is a good or bad thing for Cole?  Why?

(The absence of the father was definitely a good thing.  The physical abuse Cole had to endure in the beginning of the book was a huge factor in Cole's tough attitude and violent acts.  With the father in the picture, Cole's mother had lost her voice, so Cole really didn't have a great relationship with either parent.  With the father gone, Cole is able to regain some of his self-esteem in a positive way, and doesn't feel the need to act tough.  His mother also becomes more courageous, even testifying against him in support of her son Cole.)

*What kind of impact are Garvey and Edwin having on Cole?
*Why do you think Edwin and Garvey are so determined to help Cole?

(We can predict that Edwin and Garvey had a similar childhood and upbringing as Cole.  This prediction can be made because these two men are so empathetic and understanding of Cole.  They clearly are able to relate to him, which means they most likely see a little bit of themselves in him.  Their passion and determination in helping Cole are definitely huge factors in his success and self-improvement.